Effect of Size on Relative Impact Values for Steel Shot & Grit from Ervin Industries, Inc.

 

EFFECT OF SIZE ON RELATIVE IMPACT VALUES FOR STEEL SHOT & GRIT

The impact-energy contained in a single particle of steel abrasive is generally related to variables of particle mass and velocity, per the mathematical equation for kinetic energy:

MV2

Where velocity (wheel speed) is constant, the impact value then varies as the cube of the diameter of the abrasive particle (mass). Thus, a shot having twice the diameter of a smaller shot will have eight (8) times the impact value!

Small changes in abrasive size can have a dramatic effect on impact value, as the table below reveals:

RELATIVE IMPACT VALUES AS SIZE IS INCREASED:

Screen OpeningBase .0117”Base .0139”Base .0165Base .0197Base .0234Base .0278
.0555”           8.0X
.0469”         8.0X 4.7X
.0394”       8.0X 4.7X 2.8X
.0331”     8.0X 4.7X 2.8X 1.7X
.0278”   8.0X 4.7X 2.8X 1.7X 1
.0234” 8.0X 4.7X 2.8X 1.7X 1  
.0197” 4.7X 2.8X 1.7X 1    
.0165” 2.8X 1.7X 1      
.0139” 1.7X 1        
.0117” 1          

Example: Considering material (Base .0117") passing through an .0139" screen and retained on .0117" screen, this material is assigned an Impact Value of one (1). Then, material through .0165” and on .0139” has an Impact Value of 1.7 times the .0139”-.0117” material. Material through .0278” and on .0234” has 8 times the Impact Value of the .0139”-.0117” material.

These are tremendous changes in Impact Value. To put the relative value of 1.7 in perspective, consider these illustrations:

  • (a) If you drive your car at 55 mph — 1.7X means you'd be driving at 93 mph!
  • (b) If your bowling average is 165 — 1.7X means you'd have an average of 280!
  • (c) If your best golf drive is 220 yards — 1.7X means you'd be driving 374 yards!

Thus, in applications such as shot peening, or roll-etching, seemingly slight changes in the average work-mix size—or in the screening specifications of new shot or grit, can effect major changes in impact values. IMPACT is the name of the game in Peening and Roll-Etching. Relative Impact values should be watched most carefully! Profile is also an imperative in application where painting, coating, or bonding of the blast-cleaned surface is involved. Consequently, control of the work-mix size balance is critical in these applications, too.

Thus, extreme care should be exercised in establishing the screening specifications for a particular application. Bear in mind, the new shot or grit purchased is just the "raw material" for the "work-mix" that will be developed in the operation.

Control of the size-balance in the work-mix is the single most important challenge in an operation, because it is the work-mix that does the actual work. It will be done properly only as long as the work-mix has the proper size-balance, which, in turn, determines the impact value delivered to the work. Study of the tremendous changes in Impact Value in the table above tells the story: you must continually monitor and control your work-mix size-balance, by making frequent screen analysis of the work-mix being thrown by the blast wheel or nozzle.

Your Ervin sales representative will show you how to set-up a simple, easy operations-analysis system.

Download the Technical Bulletin here.

or Call Ervin Today at 1-800-748-0055

Ervin Resources

Find SDS, Product Brochures & Technical Bulletins
RESOURCE LIBRARY

Contact Ervin

Ervin Industries Inc. Corporate Headquarters
P.O. Box 1168, Ann Arbor, MI 48106-1168
P: (734) 769-4600 / TF: (800) 748-0055 / F: (734) 663-0136
This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.


Ervin Industries
3893 Research Park Dr
Ann Arbor, MI 48108
734-769-4600


Linked In